Matteo's Mexican Grill

Nestled in the heart of Germantown, WI, Matteo's Mexican Grill offers an inviting escape into the rich and vibrant world of authentic Mexican cuisine. This charming restaurant and bar combines a warm, welcoming atmosphere with a menu bursting with bold flavors that faithfully reflect the culinary traditions of Mexico.

Matteo’s is best known for its expertly crafted dishes like the tender Chicken Fajitas and the colorful, satisfying Burrito Santa. Fans of seafood are drawn to their renowned Fish Fry and the vibrant Seafood Salad, both prepared with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of seasoning. For those seeking heartier fare, specialties such as Tony's Molcajete — a sizzling steak stir-fry with onions, red bell peppers, and tomato — deliver a punch of flavor served over fragrant white rice. The Drowned Tacos, deep-fried and smothered in house-made mild sauce and garnished with avocado and queso fresco, are a must-try for taco lovers craving something out of the ordinary.

The bar complements the culinary offerings with an enticing selection of handcrafted drinks. Their Mango Margarita and Sangria are crowd favorites, celebrated for their fruit-forward freshness and perfectly balanced sweetness. For the adventurous, the Flight of Margaritas provides a delightful way to sample a trio of these signature cocktails. Whether you’re pairing a margarita with the crispy Chips and Salsa or enjoying a refreshing Margarita with Chips and Poblano Cheese Sauce, the drink menu adds to the overall sensory experience.

Dessert at Matteo’s is nothing short of indulgent. The Fried Ice Cream, with its crisp cornflake crust, honey drizzle, and dollop of whipped cream, offers a warm and crunchy contrast to the cool, creamy interior — a perfect sweet finish to any meal. Alternatively, the Lava Cake and Tres Leches Cake provide rich, comforting flavors that gently linger on the palate.

Guests repeatedly praise the restaurant for its warm hospitality and attentive service. Regulars highlight the friendly and knowledgeable staff who make each visit feel like a gathering among friends. Lynn Bridger and her longtime group of friends share their enthusiasm for the lively atmosphere and fantastic margaritas, while Kristi G. notes the accommodating nature of the servers who thoughtfully cater to special dietary needs without sacrificing flavor.

Whether you’re gathering for a festive lunch with friends, a family dinner, or celebrating a special occasion, Matteo’s Mexican Grill shines as a local gem where authentic flavor, vibrant energy, and genuine hospitality come together seamlessly. The passion for quality and tradition is palpable in every bite and every smile, creating an experience that invites you to return again and again.